Question:
Was there a Janis Joplin sound alike contestant on American Idol?
1970-01-01 00:00:00 UTC
Was there a Janis Joplin sound alike contestant on American Idol?
Ten answers:
2008-05-01 17:49:37 UTC
yeah that amanda chick she got the boot a while ago its a shame i liked her
2008-05-01 17:48:26 UTC
Yes,

amanda overmeyer
Messykatt
2008-05-01 17:53:40 UTC
Her name was Amanda Overmyer and she was unusually good! (I'm a Joplin fan, too). The problem is, on that show she used a Joplin type style for all their dippy song categories so it didn't sound too good.



Plug her into youtube, though...she's there!
Amanda Overmeyer-Janis of today!
2008-05-03 10:20:28 UTC
YES!!!



Her name is Amanda Overmyer.



Janis is my favorite singer, and I'm usually very picky about people doing her songs, but the moment Amanda opened her mouth, I loved her sound. She doesn't sound exactly like Janis, but she has that bluesy, southern, deep, raspy voice, and she might even be playing Janis in a movie.
?
2016-05-26 12:10:03 UTC
I think that you got Taylor Swift and Taylor Hicks (who was a contestant on american idol) mixed up!
2008-05-01 18:16:52 UTC
Amanda Overmeyer sounded like Joplin and she was fantastic. She is a nurse, rides a motorcycle, has black hair with blonde streaks on the top and sides. She was so cool. I wish she were still on. Amazing performer. I'd buy her cds.
2tweets
2008-05-02 12:25:36 UTC
I'm with the last 2 posters.Nette and Mj? sorry but thumbs up AO sucked and she "thought" she was JJ reincarnate LOL Hpe she didn't quit her Real job.
Nette on the Bayou
2008-05-01 22:06:18 UTC
Yes, and she was even worse than Joplin. She couldn't have sang a soft song (like Castro, LOL!) to save her life. I did not like her at all and I don't think she should have been even in Hollywood. Janis Joplin shouldn't have either.
mj
2008-05-02 01:35:24 UTC
Yep, a wannabee with a bad personality and not even a great singer.. She could never hold a candle to Janis.. Glad to see her go.....
Miss Understood
2008-05-01 18:01:11 UTC
Actually, Amanda Overmyer does sound a lot like Janis. Unfortunately,though,she got booted because of that because the American Idol demographic and judges just can't appreciate her Blues Rock style. But check her out on YouTube. Her best performances were her audition of Joplin's "Mean Woman" and Joan Jett's "Hate Myself For Loving You". Some of her other performances weren't so great, but that was more on the judges and the show, though. The judges always bashed her for always sounding like Janis and they tried to tell her what to sing, how to dress, how to do her hair and makeup, etc, so she kind of got to where she didn't know who to be. And then when she toned everything down a bit, they told her "this is who you are", like they really knew her. And she played along for a while and tried to be more "American Idol", but finally, she had enough. When the judges suggested that she should do a ballad,or something,she said that she won't do a ballad because ballads are stupid and aren't her and she only has a minute and a half a week to give her fans a taste of what they'll see at her shows when she's a star,so she had to be real and be herself. Then Simon said she isn't a star yet, but she said she doesn't even care if she has to sell out bars in Lafayette (she has a little Joplin attitude too). Then, the next night she was eliminated at #11,so she doesn't get to tour,which sucks because I really wanted to see her. But i think she'll be better off without Idol anyway. Then she could put out a kick-a$$ Blues Rock CD and doesn't have to worry about singing any stupid ballads :p

But she's really cool, though. How many nurses do you know who ride their own Harley (not in the b*tch seat :p)? Plus, right before she went to Hollywood, she was in a bad car crash where she ran a stoplight and got hit by a semi truck and ended up getting staples in her head,or something. But even a semi couldn't take that chick down. Anyway,though,maybe she's not the next Janis Joplin because there was only one Janis and no one else can ever be Janis, but she's definitely about the closest I've seen, especially on American Idol.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...