X Factor - Rachel Hylton. Stay or leave?

Question

I just want her gone now. I have no belief in this 'second chance pity party' they're throwing for her.

Just because she 'says' that she has changed, does it mean she actually has? After living such a vile and selfish life so far? I say not.

Every druggie, criminal is just looking for their next 'hit' and will say anything to get it.

I say, get rid!

Answer 1

I don't know the woman, but I don't like her attitude and I don't think she can sing, so yes, get rid of her. If she is serious about getting her children back or keeping the ones she has got, she will just have to work hard without the "easy option" of becoming famous on a reality show. Good luck to her if she is genuine however.

Answer 2

And how often do you listen to Amy Whinehouse, George Michael, Michael Jackson, any rock band around at the moment! If we gave no one a second chance to improve their lives, we would have no theatre, cinema, music or TV. You are being very hypocritical here - if you use any of those mediums.



OK, I don't like the girl. She might have a good voice but her attitude will make her hard to work with. I also believe that once in the public eye, any celebrity convicted of serious drug abuse or violence should not be allowed to work in the media again because of the influence they have over others. This girl does seem to have turned her life around and I would not hold what she did in her young teenage years against her unless it was flung in my face by future trouble making and abuse.

Answer 3

I want her gone, not because of her past, although I do feel sorry for her 3 kids in care and I'm sick of seeing her with the other 2 and her 'I'm doing it for ma kids'

She should have gone last week, she would have by the public vote, Louis saved her to get at Simon ! She can't sing, she shouts and she loves herself so much it makes me seethe.

I hope she goes this week then I can enjoy the rest of the series.

Answer 4

X Factor is a talent competition for singers. Rachel is a contestant who can sing.

It doesn't /shouldn't come into it , what she did some years ago - nothing to do with it

Are you saying that Katherine Jenkins should leave 'Songs of Praise' ?

Answer 5

Second Chance? More like Seventh at least! It doesn't even matter about whether she's changed or not, it doesn't mean she should just win because of it. I still think Austin shouldv'e gone through instead of her.



So YES! They should send her home!

Answer 6

I am sorry but I think you are so judgemental. We do not know the full story - what got her into drugs in the first place or what her childhood was like. She has pulled herself out of the gutter and deserves a second chance as everyone does. It is a singing contest not a 'hate you because of what you are' contest. She should be judged on her singing alone the same as the other contestants.

Answer 7

She should leave, not because of her past even though I hate druggies. But because she is a rude tart. She needs to grow up and learn the lines of her song. She keeps getting away with things that other's wouldn't. Get this b*tch out.

Answer 8

LEAVE !

She is an arrogant, selfish druggie



She will only turn out like Amy Winehouse if she won anyway, and probably end up puttin her 2 remaining kids in care, just like the rest !!



If i was her i wouldnt have broadcast that i used to be a druggie, was locked up, and had my children put into care.. doesnt paint a very good picture does it :D



xx

Answer 9

I think she should go because she is a one trick pony - every song she sings sounds the same!

Answer 10

I'm all for people having second chances in life. But she is in a talent competition and everyone should be judged by the same standard THEIR VOICE!!! not their potential so i feel she should have gone last week and will definitely not improve enough to get into the final

Answer 11

she know shes done wrong and at least she didn't hide it. she wants to change her life around and i don't want her to win because i feel sorry for her, because i don't. she got herself into that mess and doesn't deserve sympathy because she was so stupid, but shes the one trying to get herself out of that mess, and she deserves to win because she can sing.

Answer 12

Some people do change for the better!



They can become a worth while member of Society again with help and support.



Rachel has a fantastic voice and should win.



People like you should be ashamed as your attitude is one that may prevent these people moving towards making this change for a better life.

Answer 13

a vile and selfish life?...thats a pretty nasty thing to say, everyone in their life at some point has made mistakes havent they?....and people can and do change...!!!



rachel to stay...AND WIN !!!

Answer 14

i think she is a good singer.her attitude isn't that good though

i believe people can change for the better

Answer 15

oh my god, i'm so glad you think the same as me!!!

they have got to get rid of her, i cant stand her! not just because of her past tho, i actually hate everything about her, voice, personality the whole package!!

people stop voting for her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 16

i thought she sounded awful on saturday & didnt think Austin deserved to go, i think hes keep being given rubbish remixes of songs from Simon!



Theres a petition on the internet to get Austin back if you like him go sign it...



http://www.petitiononline.com/AustinD/petition.html



I just think her gob lets her down, shes always got 2have a say & never shuts up..



I personally dont think shes raw talent...diana vickers is amazin compaired to her......thats raw talent

Answer 17

She is not doing very well and she is annoying me but Daniel and Ruth can go before her.

Answer 18

Thank god everyone is not like you.Rachel has a tremendous voice and your going to be seeing alot more of her so get used to it,

Answer 19

Thats it love - well done - with your attitude those who have made mistakes in the past will never be able to move on and better themselves and make amends because people like you will keep them in the gutter. She has a great voice and deserves to be where she is. The past is past and people can and do learn from their mistakes. Its people like you who won't let them.

Answer 20

RACHEL SHOULD LEAVE. FULL STOP.

Answer 21

Leave, gobby cow.

Answer 22

they should all leave, hateful program designed by greedy hateful people to line their own pockets

Answer 23

hopefully she will be gone soon... she has no chance of winning